24/7 Claims Support • Serving trucking businesses across the United States
← Back to Blog

Safety & compliance

How Do CSA Scores and Safety Affect Truck Insurance?

Semi tractor parked beside a 'Safety first' preventive maintenance checkpoint sign

CSA scores affect truck insurance because underwriters look up your FMCSA inspection, violation and crash data by DOT number before they quote. Weak results in areas like unsafe driving, hours of service or vehicle maintenance tell the insurer to expect claims, which can mean a higher price, stricter terms or a decline. A documented safety program won't guarantee a lower premium, but it gives the underwriter a reason to see you as a better risk.

What are the CSA BASICs?

FMCSA's Compliance, Safety, Accountability (CSA) program sorts inspection and crash data into seven Behavior Analysis and Safety Improvement Categories, called BASICs:

  1. Unsafe Driving
  2. Crash Indicator
  3. Hours-of-Service Compliance
  4. Vehicle Maintenance
  5. Controlled Substances/Alcohol
  6. Hazardous Materials Compliance
  7. Driver Fitness

The Safety Measurement System (SMS) ranks carriers against similar carriers in each BASIC using roughly the last two years of data. For property carriers, the BASIC percentiles aren't public, but the inspections, violations and crashes behind them are, and underwriters read those. Carriers can log in to see their own percentiles.

FMCSA has announced that it will reorganize the BASICs into "Compliance Categories" (Federal Register, November 20, 2024), with the launch date to follow in a later notice. As of November 7, 2026 we found no launch notice, so the seven BASICs above are still the names used. The data underwriters read stays the same: inspections, violations and crashes.

How do underwriters use my safety data?

An underwriter reading your DOT number usually checks how many inspections you have had, how often trucks or drivers were placed out of service, which violations repeat, and whether any crashes were reported. A small carrier with few inspections may have no SMS percentile at all; then the individual violations matter more. Repeated violations in the same area, such as lights and tires or logbook problems, read as a habit rather than bad luck.

Which safety practices make the biggest difference?

Hire carefully and keep driver files complete

Run an MVR before hiring, check CDL and medical certificate dates, and make sure every driver is approved by your insurer before the first load. Complete driver qualification files are also one of the first things a DOT auditor asks for.

Run a real drug and alcohol testing program

CDL drivers must be in a DOT drug and alcohol testing program, with pre-employment queries in the FMCSA Drug and Alcohol Clearinghouse. Gaps here are a compliance problem first, and they show up in audits and underwriting.

Make pre-trip inspections count

Inspectors check lights, tires and brakes. A walk-around that is actually done, plus a maintenance schedule with records, keeps those violations off your SMS data.

Manage hours of service

ELD data makes hours-of-service problems easy for inspectors to find. Plan loads so drivers can run legal, and review ELD edits and unassigned driving time every week.

Coach unsafe driving early

Speeding, following too close and improper lane changes feed the Unsafe Driving BASIC. Dashcams and telematics help you spot the habit before an inspector or a crash does, and some insurers value them.

How do I fix a bad CSA history?

You can't delete accurate violations, but you can stop adding new ones, and the SMS weighs recent events more than older ones. If a violation or crash on your record is wrong, you can ask FMCSA to review it through its DataQs system. At renewal, give the underwriter a short written note on what you changed (new maintenance vendor, new hiring standard, cameras), with dates. That context helps more than a promise.

Where does this fit with the rest of my insurance?

Safety is one of the few rating factors you control every day. For the other levers, see how to lower truck insurance, and if you're a new carrier, get ready for the new entrant safety audit. Our Fleets & owner-operators page lists the safety support we provide to clients.

Frequently asked questions

Do insurance companies look at CSA scores?

Yes. Inspection results, violations and crashes reported to FMCSA are public, and underwriters routinely review them by DOT number when they quote a new account or a renewal. How heavily each insurer weighs them varies.

How long do violations stay in the Safety Measurement System?

The SMS looks at roughly the last two years of inspection and crash data, and newer events count more than older ones. FMCSA publishes the method on its CSA website and in the Federal Register.

Can I see my own CSA data?

Yes. Anyone can look up a carrier's public SMS results by USDOT number on the FMCSA SMS website, and carriers can log in to see more detail, including some data that isn't public.

What is the quickest safety fix that helps insurance?

Pre-trip inspections that actually catch lights, tires and brakes. Lights, tires and brakes are on every inspector's checklist, and problems with them are among the easiest violations to prevent.

Sources

  1. FMCSA – SMS Methodology (current edition on the CSA website): the seven BASICs – the CSA site blocks automated access; BASIC names cross-checked with the FMCSA-hosted 2013 methodology below; accessed Nov 8, 2026
  2. FMCSA – SMS Methodology, 2013 update (fmcsa.dot.gov) – accessed Nov 8, 2026
  3. FMCSA – Enhanced Carrier Safety Measurement System, 89 FR 91874 (Nov 20, 2024): planned Compliance Categories – accessed Nov 7, 2026
  4. FMCSA – Safety Measurement System (SMS) – accessed Nov 7, 2026
  5. FMCSA – Drug and Alcohol Clearinghouse – accessed Nov 7, 2026

Coverage depends on the policy terms; this is general information, not advice.

Want a quote for your operation?

Tell us about your trucks, drivers, lanes and cargo. GuildRoad Insurance Agency shops trucking markets and explains the options in plain language.

Start my quote